Deinterlacing

How to deinterlace video and get rid of the lines

You play an old tape capture or a DVD on your computer and everything that moves has fine horizontal stripes along its edges, like a comb. Nothing is broken. The video is interlaced, a trick from the days of tube TVs, and your screen is showing it the wrong way. A deinterlacer fixes it, and it's the first thing any restoration should do.

Updated

What interlacing is

Old video systems couldn't send a full picture fast enough, so they sent half of one at a time. First the odd lines (one field), then the even lines (the next field), fifty times a second in PAL countries and about sixty in NTSC ones. A tube TV drew each field as it arrived and your eye blended them.

A file stores the two fields woven together as one frame. But they were recorded a fiftieth or sixtieth of a second apart, so anything that moved sits in two places at once: one position on the odd lines, another on the even ones. A computer or modern TV shows the whole frame at once, and you see the stripes.

Almost all standard-definition tape is interlaced: VHS, S-VHS, Hi8, Video8, MiniDV and Digital8. So are most DVDs made from video, and most broadcast TV recordings. Phone video and internet downloads usually aren't.

1. Check that it's really interlaced

Pause on a frame where something moves sideways, like a hand, a car or a camera pan, and zoom in. Combing on the moving edges means interlaced. A still scene shows nothing either way, so pick a busy one.

To check the file itself, ffprobe (part of ffmpeg) prints the field order the file claims:

Read the field order
ffprobe -v error -select_streams v:0 -show_entries stream=height,field_order capture.mp4

tt or bb means interlaced, progressive means not. Files lie sometimes, especially after a re-encode, so for a second opinion let ffmpeg measure the combing itself:

Measure combing
ffmpeg -i capture.mp4 -frames:v 500 -vf idet -an -f null -

The last “Multi frame detection” line counts TFF, BFF and progressive frames. Mostly TFF or BFF means interlaced.

2. Rule out film on an NTSC DVD

Movies and many TV series were shot on film at 24 frames a second. To get them onto 30-frame NTSC video, the frames were spread over fields in a repeating 3:2 pattern called pulldown. It combs like interlaced video, but deinterlacing it is wrong: you get blur and a small stutter every fifth frame.

What it needs is inverse telecine, which puts the original 24 film frames back together. In ffmpeg that's fieldmatch,decimate (see below). PAL DVDs of films don't have this problem: film was simply sped up from 24 to 25 frames.

Home video from a camcorder is real interlaced video, so this step only matters for discs of films and TV.

3. Pick a frame rate

A deinterlacer can turn every frame into one picture, keeping the 25 or 30 frames a second you started with. Or it can turn every field into a picture, giving 50 or 60. Both are correct, and the choice is about taste:

4. Deinterlace first, before anything else

Do it at the start, on the original capture. Denoising, sharpening and upscaling all see the stripes as fine detail. A denoiser smears them into a ghostly double edge, a sharpener makes them crisper, and an upscaler bakes them into the bigger picture where no deinterlacer can find them again. And deinterlace once: two passes blur twice.

5. Save it as progressive video

Encode the result normally. If more steps follow, use a high quality setting (-crf 12 or lower in ffmpeg) so the next tool isn't working from a freshly compressed copy.

Which deinterlacer to use

Doing it yourself with ffmpeg

The free command-line tool ffmpeg does all of this. Keep the original frame rate:

Deinterlace, same frame rate
ffmpeg -i capture.mp4 -vf "bwdif=mode=send_frame:parity=auto:deint=all" \
  -c:v libx264 -crf 14 -preset slow -c:a copy deinterlaced.mp4

Double it to field rate (50 or 60) for the smoothest motion:

Deinterlace to field rate
ffmpeg -i capture.mp4 -vf "bwdif=mode=send_field:parity=auto:deint=all" \
  -c:v libx264 -crf 14 -preset slow -c:a copy deinterlaced_50p.mp4

For a film or TV series on an NTSC DVD, undo the pulldown instead. Frames that can't be matched still get deinterlaced:

Inverse telecine
ffmpeg -i film_dvd.mkv -vf "fieldmatch,bwdif=deint=interlaced,decimate" \
  -c:v libx264 -crf 14 -preset slow -c:a copy film_24p.mp4

Doing it with Phoenix

Phoenix Upscaler handles this step for you. It checks each clip, deinterlaces only when the clip is interlaced, and keeps the original frame rate. In Generative mode it also measures the combing with idet, so a capture that's wrongly labelled progressive still gets fixed and a real progressive file is left alone. Then it denoises and restores detail, in that order. It doesn't undo 3:2 pulldown, so run the inverse telecine command above on a film-sourced NTSC disc first. Phoenix runs on your own Windows or Linux PC, NVIDIA or AMD, for $129 once, and the free download restores 60-second clips with a small watermark.

Questions

Why does my old video have lines on it?

Most tape and DVD video is interlaced: each frame is two half-pictures taken a fiftieth or sixtieth of a second apart, one on the odd lines and one on the even lines. A TV showed them one after the other. A computer screen shows both at once, so anything that moved between them gets a striped edge.

What is the best deinterlacer?

QTGMC, a VapourSynth and AviSynth script, gives the cleanest result but takes real setup. In plain ffmpeg, bwdif is a little cleaner than the older yadif and just as easy. For most home tapes the difference between those two is small next to everything else that's wrong with the picture.

Should I deinterlace to 25 or 50 frames per second?

50 (or 60 for NTSC) keeps every moment the camera recorded, so motion looks smooth and live, the way it did on a TV. 25 or 30 halves the file size and looks more like film. Both are correct. Pick 50 or 60 for sports and fast action, and keep the original rate if the file is going into a slideshow or an edit.

Can deinterlacing hurt a video?

Yes, if the video wasn't interlaced. Running a deinterlacer on progressive video, like most phone clips and internet downloads, blends lines that were already fine and softens the picture. Check first, or use a mode that only touches frames marked as interlaced.

Does Phoenix Upscaler deinterlace automatically?

Yes. It deinterlaces only clips that are interlaced and keeps the original frame rate. Phoenix doesn't undo 3:2 pulldown, so run inverse telecine on a film-sourced NTSC DVD first.

Related: Restoring VHS tapes at home · Upscaling a DVD to HD · How to restore old video · Upscaling 240p and 360p video · AI video upscaling on Linux · Phoenix Upscaler guide

Try it on your own tape

The free download restores 60-second clips with a small watermark. Pick a stretch with plenty of movement and judge the result yourself.

Download Phoenix